Newswatch March 2011

To View an Online Version of this E-letter, click here

SMPTE Industry News - Monthly Tech Focused Newsletter of the Society of Motion Picture and Television Engineers

Hot Button Discussion
The HDSLR Option

Probably no tool in the motion picture world better illustrates the modern trend toward the lightning quick adoption and innovative use of a still nascent technology originally developed for entirely different applications than the headlong advance of digital single lens reflex cameras (DSLRs) into the movie and TV production paradigm. Such cameras, from several manufacturers in various flavors, were developed to revolutionize the still photography industry and, indeed, have done just that. Along the way, however, they have also become "a standard equipment requirement on many movies and TV shows," according to Rodney Charters, ASC, a well-known broadcast and feature film cinematographer (TV's "24," among others).

DSLR technology has been fundamentally changing still photography since the early 1990s, and in the past decade, has pretty much taken over that industry thanks to improvements in digital CMOS sensors and engineering that permits accurate previewing of frames up to the exact moment of exposure. Subsequently, manufacturers figured out how to make such cameras shoot true (1920 x 1080) high definition video at 29.97 frames/sec, and now at 23.976 frames/sec. This has made what are now called HDSLR cameras attractive for certain types of motion picture and broadcast work as cinematographers can use them to mimic the 35mm film format, utilize a wide range of cine-style lenses, and yet, work in a more mobile and efficient manner within a digital workflow. In fact, entire TV episodes and motion pictures, as well as segments of many others, are now being shot utilizing HDSLR cameras, and that trend is only expected to increase.

In 2010, the Fox drama "House," for instance, gained headlines when its season finale was shot entirely using the Canon EOS 5D Mark II. Cinematographer Dean Semler, ASC, incorporated HDSLR technology (the Olympus E-P1 system) into the making of the Disney feature, Secretariat, in order to capture innovative horse-racing visuals; Anthony Dod Mantle used Canon 5D's prominently for chunks of his Academy Award-winning work on Slumdog Millionaire and also on 127 Hours; and this year, several prominent movies that debuted at the Sundance Film Festival were shot with such technology, including Grand Jury prize winner Like Crazy (using the Canon 7D system) and Hell and Back Again, shot with the 5D camera, which won two awards at the Festival, including one for cinematography. All of this is merely the tip of a rapidly growing iceberg.

"I can't speak for all shows, but many (TV shows) that I know about carry a body along the lines of the Canon EOS 5D Mark II, Canon 7D, and the flip-screen Canon 60D, often with both the 5D and 7D equipped with after-market PL mounts, and they are making them essential tools," Charters adds. "For motion picture work, it allows us to be faster and more efficient, and to put the camera in places where it is hard or impossible to place a larger camera. They have therefore opened up new ways of seeing and telling a story. These cameras are small, the images are great, and the post workflow can fit into the Red or (Arri) Alexa (high-resolution video camera) workflows. We have never had cameras that cheap and versatile in 35mm production before with this kind of quality, and so, that is why they are showing up on many TV shows and feature films."

Photographer/videographer/editor/journalist Michael Guncheon, a SMPTE member, recently gave a presentation on the rise of HDSLR's in the production world at the Hollywood Post Alliance's 2011 Tech Retreat. He points out that one of the remarkable things about the technology's infiltration into the moving picture world is the fact that it has done so at such a rapid clip, with improvements possible routinely, thanks to the software revolution.

"With the (Canon 5D), what has surprised those of us who bought the cameras early on is the fact that they have been able to upgrade the firmware like they have in terms of significant things," says Guncheon. "In the past, they were doing updates to fix bugs, but not to add new features. Then, the Mark II came out, and it originally did 30 frames/sec, and everyone wanted 24 frames/sec, so they put out an upgrade to the firmware, and now it does 24 frames/sec. Shooters wanted manual exposure, and they added it. That, to me, is an amazing development."

DSLR's for consumers and for professional still photographers are, of course, available from several manufacturers. In the motion picture world, however, Canon's EOS 5D Mark II, 7D, and 60D are the most widely incorporated HDSLR's today, although major development work on such cameras is happening right now at a wide range of companies.

That very development process, however, is part of a dichotomy that prevents HDSLR's from being uniformly absorbed into the motion picture ethos. That dichotomy is the fact that, at their foundation, these are still cameras, and the people making them have huge businesses producing and selling them to consumers and professional photographers as such. Therefore, culturally and ergonomically, the development process remains geared away from what the niche world of moving pictures would ideally prefer.

"Still photography and motion pictures are probably as synergistic as a sculptor and a painter would be," Guncheon suggests. "They are different art forms, even if there are some people who do both. If you think about it, an SLR camera is designed to capture a single moment, not to wait for you to linger in the viewfinder for 12 minutes to capture a take or series of takes. It's designed to go up there, frame the shot, wait briefly for the moment to happen, and then take the picture. The ergonomics of taking a still picture and shooting video are still different things, and therefore, there are drawbacks to using (HDSLR) cameras for moving pictures. Ideally, if it were up to me, I would try to take these sensors and processors and mounts and put them into bodies that were designed more specifically for shooting motion."

Indeed, Charters calls HDSLR's "challenging beasts to use in production. In particular, the challenge of focusing the image and working with the relatively unprofessional H.264 codec on a final color pass intercut with Red or Alexa footage, since both of those shoot a raw image. Red or Alexa footage can be easily pulled up or down in exposure density and color control, but the Canon file still needs to be very accurately exposed, so there is not much room for maneuvering."

These limitations mean that image data captured this way needs to be transferred or re-formatted to a different codec for editing or other post-production functions as it travels through a project's pipeline. Additionally, sensors in DSLR's have more pixels than HD requires, so images sometimes need to be scaled down—a process that can introduce aliasing artifacts. These factors sometimes force filmmakers to debate whether, and in what circumstances, an HDSLR is a better choice than larger, more expensive professional video cameras like the aforementioned Red or Alexa cameras, or lower priced HD camcorders being targeted to compete with Canon's HDSLR technology, like Sony's new PMW-F3 camera and Panasonic's AG-AF100 series.

"Fortunately for Canon, the codec used in the PMW-F3 (long GOP MPEG at 35mps) is also not true HD," Charters adds. "The color and resolution in large-format HDSLR cameras outperforms the final, captured file. What we cinematographers are dreaming of is a raw version of the codec. With their full-size chips and excellent color rendition, that would make these cameras as good or better than most (HD video cameras) because they do not have a video look. But without better codecs, right now, no one can record the raw signal, or do justice to the raw chip size—we can't get the best image quality (out of the camera) in the way the manufacturers have chosen to have us capture the files right now."

And there are other challenges, as well, according to Guncheon.

"Recording time is limited by maximum file size, and cameras are sometimes susceptible to overheating," he says. "Monitoring on set is also somewhat difficult. A (Canon 5D) will, for example, output HD before you shoot, but when you hit record, it jumps into standard definition from the HDMI spigot, and when you plug into that spigot, then the LCD monitor on the back of the camera is no longer available. So then you need to deal with splitters and all that stuff. Right now, there are a lot of work-arounds we still have to use."

The cinematographers also point to issues such as auto focus, remote control limitations, lack of timecode and genlock, lack of 4k capabilities, rolling shutter challenges, and so on, as things that are "not quite there yet" with such cameras in terms of ideal motion-picture use. Still, that said, they admit these problems will no doubt be addressed and mitigated, just not at an ideal pace for the motion picture industry, because of the fact that the engineering for such technology is focused mainly on the still photography world's needs.

Meantime, third-party data management tools are filling the gap in many areas. A popular on-set color-correction and data management tool from Gamma & Density Co., for example, now offers a specialized Canon version of that company's 3cP software designed to smooth the data path when using the Canon EOS 5D Mark II and 7D cameras. Several manufacturers across the industry are taking similar approaches to solving data challenges. Others have developed nifty focus-pulling rigs for such cameras, including Red Rock Micro, Zacuto, IDC Photography, Cinevate, and others.

In any case, even with various quirks and limitations and the fact that HDSLR technology is in its infancy, particularly where moving pictures are concerned, their adoption into workflows and pipelines continues unabated. Perhaps the best part of this reality, Guncheon suggests, is the fact that it continues to democratize production.

"It's amazing that these tools are available to filmmakers and young people, or even people just starting or in school," he says. "They are affordable in many cases, and that lets anyone use the same tools as major filmmakers now. They can achieve many of the same looks, in fact. On the other side of the coin, like any new technology, it can get overused. A narrow depth of field, which these cameras make possible, is great, but only if you have a real creative reason for doing it. So, in the end, it still comes down to the creative motivations."

Here are links to a few popular industry sites that focus on both the art and science of HDSLR filmmaking:

DSLR Cinema
Prolost
Vincent LaForet's blog
DSLR Video Shooter
Philip Bloom
Planet 5D
Cinema 5D
Planet Nikon
5D Filmmaking
HD Video Pro

Comment
back to top

Reference to specific companies or products are made for informational purposes only and do not constitute SMPTE endorsement, recommendation, or promotion.

News Briefs
HD ENG Options

An interesting recent Pro HD Executive Report prepared for JVC Broadcast by industry consultant Tore Nordahl breaks down the various options available to local TV stations that wish to shoot and distribute HD news content from the field in a timely and budget-conscious way. Nordahl approaches the topic from the point of view that most homes in the near future will have three different types of home viewing screens to receive broadcast content—a standard, wired television, a mobile or wireless television, and a desktop PC television. He also postulates that 720p60 is a reasonable quality standard to broadcast local TV content. To achieve that standard, Nordahl offers various possibilities for transmitting live HD ENG broadcasting signals locally. He suggests that a potentially important method for sending such signals from the field will be through the use of multiple, bonded 4G uplink connections. After reading the report, you can hear Nordahl discuss these concepts further in a podcast with Broadcast Engineering magazine here.

Comment
back to top

Google vs. Content Farmers

The Web is abuzz with discussion these days about the delicate issue of content farming and what Google, and others, are trying to do about it. Google recently announced an update to its search algorithms designed to mitigate the frequency with which sites that post no original content or simple gibberish for the purpose of attaining high Web search rankings turn up prominently in searches. Such sites' purpose is to circumvent Google's site ranking system—hence, the nickname "content farming." Several technology writers across the Web, however, are concerned that Google's new algorithm could have an unintended impact on legitimate sites, particularly smaller ones that lack the resources to work with Google or around any restrictions that crop up unintentionally. TechNews World has an interesting examination of this concern, and PC Magazine columnist Lance Ulanoff also has thoughts about potential consequences of this ongoing battle.

Comment
back to top

Thunderbolt Hits

Amid the hoopla in late February over Apple's announcement of a new line of MacBook Pro computers was a little noticed detail—Intel was simultaneously announcing its newest file transfer technology, dubbed Thunderbolt. The reason the two announcements went together is that, for now, Thunderbolt is only available with new MacBook Pros, and in any case, like any new file transfer technology, it will take a while to become widely adopted. That said, Intel is insisting the technology can transfer files at a rate of 10 gbits/sec—faster than USB or Firewire. CNN Tech has an early report on Thunderbolt, and Business Insider offers assurances that the MacBook Pro is only the beginning of the devices Thunderbolt will shortly be plugging into. Everything from Avid editing systems to professional video cards to external hard drives will eventually get the Thunderbolt treatment, according to the report.

Comment
back to top

Let us know what you think about SMPTE Newswatch! Provide suggestions and feedback on improving this newsletter by completing this brief survey.

back to top

Table of Contents

The HDSLR Option

HD ENG Options

Google vs. Content Farmers

Thunderbolt Hits

 

Connect with Us

SMPTE Events

9-10 April 2011
DCS 2011
Las Vegas, NV

2011 SMPTE Regional Seminars
US and Canada
Thursday, 12 May, Montreal, Canada
Saturday, 14 May, Toronto, Canada
Tuesday, 24 May, Atlanta, GA
Thursday, 26 May, Easton, MA

6-7 June 2011
Bits on the Bay
Washington, DC Section
Chesapeake, MD

21-22 June 2011
SMPTE 2nd Annual International Conference on Stereoscopic 3D for Media and Entertainment
New York, NY

19-22 July 2011
SMPTE Australia Conference and Exhibition
Sydney, Australia

8-13 September 2011
IBC Conference
Amsterdam, The Netherlands

24-27 October 2011
SMPTE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition
Hollywood, CA

 

 

Get more information about SMPTE.

 

To advertise in this e-newsletter, contact Jeff Victor at jeffvictor@comcast.net or 847-367-4073.
Eletter created by Cavich Creative, LLC

Click here to unsubscribe.

 

3 Barker Avenue, White Plains, NY 10601